Bitcoin
and other cryptocurrencies continue to grow in popularity, but if you're
considering investing in them, there are some key things you should know first.
Beyond
learning the basics of cryptocurrency, investors should keep in mind a myriad
of risks, including that the price of even the most popular cryptocurrencies is
volatile, markets are not very transparent, transactions are irreversible,
consumer protections are minimal or non-existent, and regulators are still
figuring out how to regulate them. We do not recommend that investors wishing
to invest in cryptocurrencies consider them as speculative assets using funds
outside of a traditional long-term portfolio.
Let's
take a closer look at some of the issues surrounding them:
What
does the SEC take on cryptocurrencies?
The
Securities and Exchange Commission has generally been skeptical of
cryptocurrencies, with chairs expressing concerns that the product is too
volatile, that investor protections are inadequate, and that regulations are
inadequate, although current SEC Chairman Gary Gensler has said on several
occasions that he has no dealings. The transaction ideal objective is to try to
invalidate them. The agency has rejected several applications by
exchange-traded funds (ETFs) investing directly in bitcoin over the past few
years.
In
August 2021, SEC Chair Gary Gensler said he was open to the idea of ETFs that
invest in cryptocurrency futures, but not the spot market, as futures markets
are already regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. In October
2021 the first two Bitcoin Futures ETFs—the Proshare Bitcoin Strategy ETF
(BITO) and the Valkyrie Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BTF)—were approved and launched.
Although a few others have followed, they have all been limited to Bitcoin and
Ethereum, as these are the two cryptocurrencies for which an active futures
market is currently established.
Will
Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies become the new global currency?
Until
there is proper regulation and consumer protection, we think not, but only time
will tell. To be viable, a currency generally needs three characteristics:
·
It
can be used as a cheap, reliable medium of exchange;
·
It
can be a unit of account;
·
It
can be a store of value and respected legal tender as a means of payment.
As
long as Bitcoin is subject to high volatility and hefty transaction fees, it
seems likely that it will have only limited use as a medium of exchange, unit
of account or store of value. Another obstacle to wider public acceptance as a
true currency is that, as cryptocurrencies become more widespread, the risk of
regulation increases – removing part of their appeal to investors who perceive
them as a currency not governed by central bank policy. National governments.
Can
Bitcoin be used as a hedge against inflation?
Because
the value of Bitcoin is not currently tied to the value of a basket of goods or
services, its value as an inflation hedge is speculative and unpredictable.
Throughout 2021 and 2022, Bitcoin has experienced both sharp rallies and sharp
price declines even as inflation data has been consistently higher. Whether
Bitcoin will prove to be an effective inflation hedge, in the long run, is yet
to be determined.
How
is cryptocurrency taxed?
The
IRS currently considers Bitcoin to be property, not currency. Cryptocurrency
transactions are taxable by the IRS whenever a taxable event occurs, such as
selling bitcoin for a fiat currency, paying for a product or service with
bitcoin, or trading it for another asset. Currently, investors are responsible
for tracking profits and other reporting on a cost basis. For help, read IRS
Notice 2014-21, or consult a tax advisor.
However,
the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 (IIJA) which was passed in
November 2021, requires cryptocurrency exchanges to report cryptocurrency
transactions on Form 1099-B beginning in 2023. Additionally, IIJA requires a
currency exchange of $10,000 or more. The IRS, similar to the current Form 8300
reporting requirements for cash transactions, begins in 2023. However, it is
important to note that this $10,000 reporting requirement does not mean that
cryptocurrency transactions of less than $10,000 are not taxable. The tax code
states that "all income from any source" is taxable, even if it is
not reportable to the IRS. For example, a person who sold $500 worth of items
at a flea market owes tax on the income, even though it was not reported to the
IRS on a Form 1099.
Are
cryptocurrency trades subject to wash-sale rules?
Tax
experts believe that because the IRS currently considers cryptocurrencies to be
property, not securities, and losses are treated separately from stocks and
mutual funds, the wash-sale rules generally do not apply. However, as new rules
are proposed and adopted, the IRS and SEC may issue new guidance on this matter
in the future.
What
are some of the risks of Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies?
·
Financial
loss. The price of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies has historically been
extremely volatile, and fluctuations can result in significant losses if sold
at the wrong time.
·
Future
regulations. Issuing and trading cryptocurrencies is currently not well
regulated and additional oversight and regulation is likely in the future. US
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has cited her concerns about cryptocurrencies
being used for "illegal financing".
·
Fraud
and Cybercrime. This has already happened. Given the above concerns,
cryptocurrencies may come under investigation from the Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network (FinCEN) for non-compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA)
and anti-money laundering requirements. Bitcoin exchanges have suffered
computer outages due to overwhelming demand, and because ledgers are kept on
the Internet, a large-scale cyber attack could limit access in an emergency –
something unlikely with cash or gold.
·
theft
or damage. A login ID and password is usually required to access a
cryptocurrency exchange. If it is lost, hacked or stolen, access may be denied
or lost. Although unusual, bitcoins can be stored in physical wallets, so they
can be spent without a computer; This creates the same risk inherent in all
cash: they can be lost, stolen or destroyed by accident.
Does
Schwab recommend investing in cryptocurrencies?
Bitcoin
and other cryptocurrencies are speculative investments in our view. We do not
believe that Bitcoin fits the traditional asset allocation model at this time,
as it is not a traditional commodity like gold, nor a conventional currency.
Bitcoin's dramatic volatility is largely driven by supply and demand, not
intrinsic value. Bitcoin has no revenue or earnings. It does not include the
price-to-earnings ratio, price-to-sales ratio, or book value. Traditional
quality metrics don't apply, so there's no way to measure the quality that we support
or encourage.
Whether
you should invest in cryptocurrency depends on your goals and preferences as an
investor, just as it does with any asset or security. We recommend that clients
use this as a speculative investment and consider the high volatility and risk
involved. For those who already have a diversified portfolio and a long-term
investment plan, we see cryptocurrency ownership outside of traditional
portfolios.